Madonna - Borderline (Sire)

Not having succumbed to the Madonna charm, this sounds like just another American disco record to me. Still, those admirers of her looks, dancing and maybe even her voice should enjoy this. It's pleasant but forgettable mainly because the sparkle and originality of "Holiday" is nowhere to be seen. (Karen Swayne, No 1, May 26, 1984)

That's 'borderline' as in 'this week's effort is pretty borderline as a song and will be lucky if it borders on the charts'. Will somebody please give this girl real songs instead of excuses? (Ian Cranna, Smash Hits, May 24, 1984)